Showing posts with label follies of the times. Show all posts
Showing posts with label follies of the times. Show all posts

Have We Brought Back the Freak Show?

|

I have some questions for Christian and/ or socially conservative friends on social media. It's not my intent to rebuke anyone, but to raise an issue for reflection. This is probably too heavy a topic for the middle of Easter Week, but it's on my mind because as we try to get a handle on how to oppose the "transing" of America's youth, all my social media feeds have become visually very disturbing, as everyone seems to feel the need to document the deranged people caught up in this movement. It strikes me that every time I have seen a deeply disturbing picture or video of an obviously disturbed individual in the past several years -- the kind of image for which I try to practice old-fashioned custody of the eyes out of protection of my own heart and the other person's dignity-- it has been in the feed not of my progressive friends flaunting sexual transgression and imposing their libertine ways on me (I say that tongue in cheek) but in the feed of "pro-family" or Christian authors tut-tutting the latest outrage. Yes, I am telling you my lefty friends' posts are in a certain respect more wholesome and PG-rated than many of my Christian and pro-family friends.

Here are my questions, in no particular order.
1) I understand the need to educate people about threats or potential threats to civil society and family life. Does every troubled person doing something weird rise to the level of cultural threat? Is it possible that some practices are so isolated and bizarre that they will never catch on as a trend, and it would be better to pass over them in silence than to publicize them? 2) What was wrong with the old-fashioned circus freak shows? Anything? Aren't many of the photos and videos that accompany weird practices of merely prurient interest? What good is served by thrusting those photos in the faces of those who see your posts? 3) Is it possible that that certain notorious transgressive accounts have been exposed enough and don't require further documentation -- we now get what these people are about? Is there a point at which we cross the line from reporting to marketing for the transgressive? 4) When we invite people to gawk at disturbing behavior, often behavior we know or reasonably assume is associated with serious mental illness, isn't that use of a person, betraying his or her human dignity? 5) Similarly, if we illustrate our stories and posts about trends we think are harmful with (possibly) prurient pictures, aren't we guilty of using people?

6) When we easily pass along images that are deliberately intended to shock and disturb, do we have any responsibility to shield our audience in some way so they have an option not to see them? (Twitter, for example, allows you to tag your own photo as possibly disturbing). (Tangentially related: not so long ago a certain sector of Christian twitter got into a discussion about the prudence of the use of foul language if you're an influential evangelical or Catholic writer. Interestingly, some of the folks most adamant that the F-bomb does not befit a professing Christian's social media page are pretty blithe in passing along images that cannot be unseen and I would argue probably shouldn't be seen. Isn't it possible sick images are more powerful and therefore more potentially soul-damaging than an F-bomb?

Maybe This Is How The Boomers Die?

|
The sheer number of the "luminaries" of pop culture and politics who have been abruptly ushered off the scene in this sexual harassment purge reminds me of something my dad used to point out about the Hollywood blacklist.  The studios loved the blacklist and used it to avoid having to pay the best writers what they were worth. Apparently quite a few "blacklisted" screenwriters still got work under pseudonyms -- but the studios were then able to pay them entry level wages instead of the big bucks their big names and previous successes should have commanded. 

Watching people like Charlie Rose and John Conyers and Garrison Keillor fall makes me wonder, quite apart from the morality and politics of it all-- if this is how the old guard is finally convinced to retire and make way for young people. 

Free Love, But No Lovers

|
I will try to say this delicately as I'm still of the mind that certain topics are not for mixed company -- and plus, my mom might be reading. 
Among the things that make me sad about the apparently bottomless pit of unseemly revelations about our celebrities (in every field) is that for all of "free love's" promise of beautiful, healthy, unrepressed sexual experiences, the actual experiences people are having are ugly, tawdry, solipsistic, and self-ruining. Co-eds getting massively drunk to force themselves (for what reason?) to be with men they can't look at sober; and men who because of their positions wouldn't lack for willing partners, yet can't approach a woman in normal fashion -- they can only seek admiration for themselves in bizarre ways. 
I mean, forget anti-harassment training. How about just sisterly advice: she does not want to see that. Even if she likes you and wouldn't mind being seduced, she doesn't. If you were a lover and not Narcissus, you would know that.
I try to be a nice Catholic girl, so I'm not on board with extra-marital sexual expression in the first place. I think the much-mocked traditional morality does a much better job of allowing sex to be beautiful and guilt-free and life-giving in both the literal and emotional senses. But this behavior isn't merely immoral, it's inhuman and degraded. It's libido turned inward towards the self instead of outward towards the other. 
My godfather used to say that if you're going to go to hell, you should go first class. This ain't it. This is more like a vision of hell itself. And it makes me feel terribly sad.

Parenting Level: Florida

|
I don't know when "everyone in Florida is crazy" became a thing, but all of a sudden there are a spate of stories on a regular basis in which people in Florida do bizarre things. Such as this couple, who used drugs to bribe their kids to clean their rooms.

Alas, the reporter does not think to ask the one truly relevant question: did it work?

Not The Chemical Weapons You Are Looking For?

|
For ten years the Grey Lady has insisted there were absolutely, positively, no chemical weapons in Iraq. Today she says, "there, like, totally were chemical weapons in Iraq," but the government lied about finding them -- even though they were reported in the 2004 Duelfer report as she herself admits.

The policy seems to be: if chemical weapons caches might support the policy of the president you hate, they don't exist. If ten years later you can use those same non-existent caches to pitch a "US bad to its own soldiers" story to your editors, well suddenly an ontological change occurs and those weapons become highly, highly significant.

Update: the more I think about this story, the more it burns me. I will let Gabriel Malor spell out why, but the gist is that Bush NEVER claimed Saddam had an active weapons program. Read the speeches again (they're linked at Malor's piece).

The first sentence is an absolute lie, uttered at Bush 43's expense, and made to justify the terrifying conclusion, laid at Obama's feet, in the last sentence.
This NYTimes piece has an overarching political goal: to cement forever the lie that the Iraq War was directed solely at stopping an active weapons of mass destruction program in Iraq. As we know, the military never found an active weapons program, which makes this a particularly compelling slander.
[...]
So let me remind you about the actual casus belli for the Iraq War.
In 2002, Saddam Hussein was doing everything he could to foil the UN weapons inspections teams about his existing weapons caches (the ones the NYTimes just "found" in its hit piece). You might recall, the U.S. was enforcing no-fly zones over Iraq at the time and attempting to ensure that Hussein remained disarmed. Hussein, for his part, was attempting to obscure both what he was capable of doing and what WMD, particularly biological and nuclear, remained to him. He was well-known, of course, for using chemical weapons against his own people and against the Iranians. Of particular concern going forward were his nuclear plans and the possibility that he would sell or give weapons to terrorists with Western ambitions.
On September 12, 2002, Bush went to the UN to plead with the useless world body to actually enforce sanctions and impose thorough weapons inspections. Nowhere in his speech will you find a claim that Hussein had an "active weapons program," as the NYTimes writers would now have you believe. Rather Bush talked about finding Hussein's old weapons and deterring his hope to once again restart his weapons programs



RTWT

No Service for Jews

|
Belgian Doctor Refuses Treatment to Jewish Patient reads the headline. A woman's son called a health hotline for her, and was told to let her go to Gaza, where she'd find pain relief. The story includes other alarming news:
Joods Actueel editor-in-chief Michael Freilich said the incident is particularly alarming because it comes amid a string of recent incidents which involved boycotts against Jews in Belgium since the start of Israel’s attack on Hamas in Gaza on July 8.
Since then, an Orthodox Jewish woman was refused service at a clothes store in Antwerp, and police removed a sign in French and Turkish from a café near Liege which said dogs were allowed but Zionists and Jews were not.
What the story doesn't tell me is if (as I assume) these are Arab immigrants doing these things or generalized anti-Semitism. 

Who Is Pushing Impeachment Talk?

|
Democrats, obviously. Not denying that Sarah Palin and a few other outliers like the idea, but nobody serious on the GOP side wants that -- it's to take eyes of the Senate prize. But to prove the point, Nate Silver counts the actual numbers. 
The scoreboard so far in July: Fox News has 95 mentions of impeachment, and MSNBC 448. That works out to about 2.7 mentions per hour of original programming on MSNBC, or once every 22 minutes. 
As he points out, impeachment talk from Dems has Br'er Rabbit quality to it.  

The Commentary Writes Itself

|
Comes the news the Associated Press Will Use Robots To Write Articles. 
The venerated AP now plans to generate and sell thousands of automated business articles a year. The robot-written stories will bring up the AP's story count in this area by an order of magnitude,Poynter reports.

Oh, please. There hasn't been anything but formulaic reporting in an AP business story in 20 years. As we have documented previously. And we all know the Formerly Grey Lady has been using robots in its commentary section forever. 

WaPo Editors Don't Know What an Idiom Is

|
Surely the stupidest thing WaPo has ever published is this bit of old tosh on the Maryland state motto. Some dude who proclaims himself a translator says it is "sexist in any language." The motto in English is "Strong deeds, gentle words," but the author has himself in a snit because the Italian original is "“Fatti maschii, parole femine."

“Fatti maschii, parole femine” (the second word is pronounced with a hard K sound, “mask-ee”) is an old Italian proverb. According to the state of Maryland, the phrase translates to “strong deeds, gentle words.” Yet this is willfully misleading. The direct translation is hardly gentle: “Manly deeds, womanly words.” I’m a professional literary translator of Italian, but don’t just take it from me.
Giuseppe Patota, the director of the Garzanti Italian Dictionary in Milan, says that the phrase “has distinctly sexist connotations, and the translation proposed by the state of Maryland misses its literal meaning.”
The first comment on the piece gets the only possible reaction just right: "Oh fer crissakes."

Misses the literal meaning? Or accurately translates the meaning of an expression? Have we fallen so far that a linguist, a professional translator and whatever editors might exist at WaPo online can't recognize an idiom when they see it?

Next installments from this guy:
  • Midwesterners are backwards and don't understand biology: elbows don't really have grease. 
  • "To be caught red-handed" is an anti-Native American slur.
The author is said to be working on a book on translation. Oy!

If Only Those Who Pay Little Attention to the Pope Would Stop Commenting On Him For Lent

|
A Michael Sean Winters blog post had some folks in my neighborhood exorcised the other day because we're pretty sure it's our parish he's complaining about here -- for the terrible crime of praying the prayer to St. Michael the Archangel after every Mass.
At another nearby parish, the pastor, one year older than myself, also has the congregation recite the prayer at the end of Mass.  This "fashion" is making a comeback with some of our younger priests, and I do not think it bodes well. I am all for a Marian hymn after Mass. But, bringing my namesake into strikes me as evidence of an agenda or, perhaps, an ideology. 
I don't understand the point of the post, which opens by invoking Pope Francis' alleged view that young people liking the Extraordinary Form mass is just a fad but turns into a rant against anyone praying to St. Michael. The connection being, EVERYONE prayed the St. Michael prayer in the old days, so ANYONE praying it now must be up to no good.

I'm not sure what difference it makes if the EF mass or St. Michael prayer IS a fad. So what? It's a big church, people can have the devotions they wish -- that seems to be the Pope's point, no? He doesn't think the EF is going anywhere long-term and he may or may not be right, but he doesn't show any appetite for crushing it either. In any case, why would you stop anyone from praying -- and especially to your own namesake?

What would be the dangerous ideology Winters fears? Belief that the devil is real and should be opposed? (Since St. Michael is invoked against "the snares of the devil.")

My reason for bringing this up, however, is that whatever the Pope thinks of the EF Mass, you cannot invoke him against the prayer to St. Michael, seeing as how last July he consecrated the entire Vatican to St. Michael.
Michael - which means "Who is like God" - is the champion of the primacy of God, of His transcendence and power. Michael struggles to restore divine justice and defends the People of God from his enemies, above all by the enemy par excellence, the devil. And St. Michael wins because in him, there is He God who acts. This sculpture reminds us then that evil is overcome, the accuser is unmasked, his head crushed, because salvation was accomplished once and for all in the blood of Christ. Though the devil always tries to disfigure the face of the Archangel and that of humanity, God is stronger, it is His victory and His salvation that is offered to all men. We are not alone on the journey or in the trials of life, we are accompanied and supported by the Angels of God, who offer, so to speak, their wings to help us overcome so many dangers, in order to fly high compared to those realities that can weigh down our lives or drag us down. In consecrating Vatican City State to St. Michael the Archangel, I ask him to defend us from the evil one and banish him.
So there. If you're going to comment on the pope's doings, at least pay attention to them.

Grey Lady's Children In Revolt

|
Well, not really, but it's satisfying in a schadenfreude-y way to know the NYT's reporters are ashamed of its editorial page, which they find doctrinaire and irrelevant and often flat wrong, and can't stand its editor, Andrew Rosenthal, who is a mean-spirited bully. (A doctrinaire liberal? Mean? Say it isn't so!)

A few tantalizing excerpts:
One former business reporter remarked that the entire business section viewed the editorial page as “irrelevant” and went on to say, “Their business editorials were relatively rare and really bad. Floyd Norris went up there to make the business editorials better and eventually just left because he got tired of trying to explain economics to them.”

And:
The Observer heard from two different sources about a posting created by respected health reporter Catherine Saint Louis and shared among her friends that pointed out a bevy of bad thinking made by the editorial page in a recent editorial related to the Affordable Care Act. In it, Ms. Saint Louis detailed the many errors in the piece’s coverage and asserted that “the basic premise is wrong.” (The Observer agreed not to share the post itself, since the person who shared it with The Observer did not have permission from Ms. Saint Louis to do so.)
There are multiple complaints about no one being allowed to use the word "should" outside the editorial page. And everyone seems to feel ashamed of Tom Friedman. Here's just one of several remarks:
Asked if this stirring resentment toward the editorial page might not just be garden variety news vs. edit stuff or even the leanings of a conservative news reporter toward a liberal editorial page, one current Times staffer said, “It really isn’t about politics, because I land more to the left than I do to the right. I just find it …”
He paused for a long time before continuing and then, unprompted, returned to Mr. Friedman. “I just think it’s bad, and nobody is acknowledging that they suck, but everybody in the newsroom knows it, and we really are embarrassed by what goes on with Friedman. I mean anybody who knows anything about most of what he’s writing about understands that he’s, like, literally mailing it in from wherever he is on the globe. He’s a travel reporter. A joke. The guy gets $75,000 for speeches and probably charges the paper for his first-class airfare.”
Yummy as it is, that's just gossip, but this is interesting:
Another sign of a loss of influence may have been revealed this past fall. A member of then Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s inner circle who remained in City Hall until the end of Mr. Bloomberg’s term told The Observer that the entire administration was “shocked” by the Times’ inability to drag its endorsed candidates over the goal line, referring to Christine Quinn in the mayoral primary and Dan Garodnick in the City Council speaker race. “When was the last time The New York Times lost both? Those are both essentially Democratic primaries, and the Times couldn’t carry any water.” The Times also endorsed Dan Squadron for advocate; he was defeated by Letitia James.
RTWT.

Annals of Self-Awareness, 6

|
This piece would be annoying enough if it weren't running the same week as the JFK retrospective. I will let John Zmirak comment, copying and pasting from his Facebook page.
The NY Times ran the column [linked above] by a liberal Pole contemptuous of those who think that the plane crash that decapitated the Polish government in 2010 on the way to visit Russia to commemorate the Katyn massacre. Because it is SO absurd to suspect anything like that of the Russian secret service, right? (I'm not saying it was a conspiracy, but it certainly had the smell of one.) The column presents the mourning over these conservative politicians' deaths as a sick fetish cult, and the suspicion as proof of paranoia--TWO WHOLE YEARS after the investigation was completed.

So what do we think of the NY Times' fetish cult of JFK? Of liberals' STILL trying to blame Dallas conservatives for a shot fired by a Communist into an anti-Communist president? Of the endless conspiracy theories, peddled by crackpots like Oliver Stone? FIFTY YEARS LATER.

That's okay, though. Americans need time to heal.

They'll Blame Entrepreneurs For Anything

|
From Saturday's Knoxville News-Sentinel

But since 10,000+ dead and a humanitarian emergency is no joke, here is where to send help. A friend in Manila writes, "I have seen the Red Cross on the ground,"  and MD Cath Conference is recommending Catholic Relief Services. A second friend in Manila also mentioned the Red Cross -- and also Caritas.

Americans Aren't Haters

|
Periodically my corner of the internets will erupt with multiple postings similar to this one. Some hack journalist has a show called "What Would You Do?"  From the clips I've seen, it seems to be like a diseased "Candid Camera" wherein actors play scenes in which some white dude crudely bullies an innocent minority behind a counter and the camera watches people's reactions.

Usually someone responds particularly eloquently or heroically, and that's what prompts the viral postings. These clips tick me off, however, because the whole premise of the shows seems to be that there is deep latent racism and malice in the hearts of most Americans and we're supposed to be amazed and proud of the one guy who stands up to it. You can almost feel the condescension: most Americans suck, but I am enlightened enough to value the good guy in this clip.

Yet the clips NEVER show Americans behaving badly. They always reveal the opposite; everyone behaves well -- standing up to the bully or the bigot or at the very least being visibly upset by the behavior and thinking about what to do.

Every once in a while there might be a lone jerk who comes into the store and kind of smirks his approval of the bully actor's nasty comments -- but, as happens in the clip above, when questioned privately, even the jerk's point of view turns out to be a little more nuanced than outright bigotry.

As I say, the show ticks me off. The people who send its clips around virally tick me off, because they too are so eager to believe Americans are sour, closed-minded cretins. No one ever notices that it's the cretins who are few and far between.

All of this is just a lengthy prelude to a review my Spy in Virginia just sent me of The Book of Matt -- the forthcoming work of a gay journalist who, after several years and 100s of interviews, has concluded that Matthew Shepard was not killed for being gay, but by his gay lover on a meth binge. 

The entire anti-bullying curriculum in our schools (the one where grown-ups teach kids not to bully by laying a steaming heap of emotional bullying on them ) was generated largely in response to Shepard's murder. It will be astonishing (and yet in another way not even slightly surprising) if it turns out the whole story was a big lie perpetrated by the killers to get off more easily, but foisted on the rest of us by ingenuous journalists eager to believe their fellow citizens are boors. It's the folks who easily believe these stories who are bigots -- it was easier to believe folks out West were a bunch of brutal redneck thugs than to investigate what actually happened.  

Dude, That's What Marriage Is For

|
I should stop being surprised by anything the Formerly Grey Lady says, but I'm still appalled at this.

A man and woman were living together and did a round of IVF together, producing a child. The woman struggled mightily with depression and killed herself, orphaning her child. The law cannot recognize the boyfriend as the child's father --neither biologically nor legally is he-- and so a custody case is dragging out and the kid is languishing in foster care instead of home with someone who loves him.

Grey Lady's conclusion? The poor man is one of an increasing number of victims
fallen prey to a system that excessively privileges the conventional family models from which there seems to be a growing exodus.
Victim?  Gee, if only there were a civil institution aimed at stabilizing the relationship between parents and their offspring, giving kids the parents they need and expressing legally and culturally the "deep commitment to starting a family" the bereaved boyfriend says he and the deceased had.

When Did Michael Savage Start Writing For Pravda?

|
I can't stand it. Pravda praises Reagan, denounces Obama's Soviet-style policies.
Recently, Obama has been re-elected for a 2nd term by an illiterate society and he is ready to continue his lies of less taxes while he raises them. He gives speeches of peace and love in the world while he promotes wars as he did in Egypt, Libya and Syria. He plans his next war is with Iran as he fires or demotes his generals who get in the way.
... liberalism is a psychosis . O'bomber even keeps the war going along the Mexican border with projects like "fast and furious" and there is still no sign of ending it.  He is a Communist without question promoting the Communist Manifesto without calling it so. How shrewd he is in America. His cult of personality mesmerizes those who cannot go beyond their ignorance. They will continue to follow him like those fools who still praise Lenin and Stalin in Russia.  Obama's fools and Stalin's fools share the same drink of illusion.
And:
The red, white and blue still flies happily but only in Russia. Russia still has St George defeating the Dragon with the symbol of the cross on its' flag. The ACLU and other atheist groups in America would never allow the US flag with such religious symbols. Lawsuits a plenty against religious freedom and expression in the land of the free. Christianity in the U.S. is under attack as it was during the early period of the Soviet Union when religious symbols were against the law.  

Pander Rays

|
Manta Rays, Rebecca Pilkington-Vincett, shamelessly pinched from here.

I'm no fan of Descartes, but we could sure use some clear and distinct ideas. As opposed to this example of fuzzy thinking: Scientists rush to save manta rays, the "pandas of the sea."
I'm not certain we should trust the judgment of "scientists" who think the creature pictured is like a panda, but the indistinct thinking doesn't stop with that absurd comparison:
“They’re such an iconic species, beloved by divers,” said Andrea Marshall, director of the Marine Megafauna Foundation, who came up with the description during an interview with NBC News. “They’re just amazing.”
I submit that the words "iconic" and "amazing" as used in this paragraph have no meaning; they just sound good to the speaker. "Iconic" refers to a work of art "executed in accordance with tradition or convention," which is clearly not what she means. And "amazing" is a word women have made into a catch-all term. The dinner is "amazing," her make-up was "amazing," the work-out was "amazing," the kindness of her friend is "amazing." Absolutely everything on Pinterest is "amazing.

So what we have is some vague assertions amounting to: "I like manta rays."  Of course, she's entitled, but it's not "science."

Scientists are "rushing" to "save" the manta rays, but it's not clear what action they are taking that constitutes a "rush" and we don't actually know if mantas need saving:
Globally we don’t know how many manta rays there are,” said Guy Stevens, director of the U.K.-based Manta Trust, whose research is largely based around manta populations in the Maldives.But -- again, like the panda -- scientists think it’s a small population.
“If they’re lucky, (manta rays) have two pups (over several years). That’s a very low reproductive rate, especially compared to your average fish,” said Dr. Heidi Dewar, a biologist at the Southwest Fisheries Science Center, part of NOAA.
Anecdotal evidence suggests mantas are under threat, and China may be a major reason for it.
The story continues with the assertion that a new fad in Chinese "traditional" medicine is endangering all the mantas...but then when they visit traditional medicine practitioners, they don't find any manta parts.
Visits to random TCM shops in Beijing and Shanghai turned up no gill rakers. In fact, a veteran pharmacist at Tongrentang, a long-established purveyor of traditional Chinese and herbal medicines, said she had never heard of manta rays being used this way.
Then comes this complaint: 
Groups like Manta Trust are focusing on getting manta rays listed by the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES). But scientists have their work cut out for them.
“It’s very difficult to get listed on CITES.  They ask for a lot of detail that is difficult to pin down,” said Marshall.  “Maybe in the terrestrial world, biologists can provide those kinds of details.  When you’re talking about the megafauna [or large marine species] world, it’s very difficult.”
Wow, it must be a real drag, having to produce empirical evidence before a body will create internationally enforceable rules. And does this time-consuming evidence gathering constitute the "rushing" of the headline?

We're then treated to a series of admissions that we don't know beans about manta rays.
Vexing questions include the manta’s life span, details of their reproductive ecology and migratory patterns. “I could wrap my life up in 20 minutes if I could talk to them,” she joked.  “It has been driving me insane for the last ten years because I haven’t been able to figure out where they give birth.  It’s 2012 and nobody has ever seen a manta give birth in the wild.” 
And research is painstaking. For one, concentrations of the animal tend to be around far-flung islands. Stevens of Manta Trust cited the costs of tracking mantas and the difficulty in locating and knowing how to study them.
So we don't know anything about manta reproduction, but we know that they only have two pups every five years? And: 
“I think it’s fascinating,” said Dewar of the Southwest Fisheries Science Center, “that there is such a large and amazing [!] creature that has so many mysteries attached to it.”
Well, that last part is splendid: that the earth still contains mysteries to unravel and that people should approach those mysteries with child-like wonder.

But to review what we've learned from this story:
  • Manta rays are just like pandas...in no way whatsoever.
  • Scientists are "rushing" to aid mantas with no specific action.
  • Scientists wish to "save" a species for which there is no evidence of its being endangered.
  • We know nothing about manta reproduction, which is one of the great mysteries, but can say with certainty that they give birth to about two pups in a lifetime.
  • Chinese medicine may be responsible for over-fishing of mantas, though there's no evidence of this apart from a lady seeing a fishing boat in the Maldives once.
Which all amounts to: Andrea Marshall and her colleagues are intrigued by manta rays. I would have enjoyed the story more -- and probably learned more-- if that had been the angle rather than: scientists hope for more research money and therefore invent a crisis and a bad guy out of whole cloth.

And Now for A Moment of Journalism

|
Mr. W. can't help himself. He obsessively reads the polls in the swing states. Of course his eyes are particularly on Ohio, so he just brought me this interesting piece from the Cincinnati Enquirer (Romney, Obama, tied the poll says).

Do journalists think about what they're writing? 'Cuz here's one portion of the story:
-- Presidential debates don't matter much in making up voters' minds. Sixty-two percent said the debates wouldn't have an impact on their decisions. Twenty-three percent said the debates made them more likely to vote for Romney, 14 percent for Obama.
I can see what the reporter means. She's just trying to express the fact that 62% of voters claim to be not much affected by debates. But if 23% moved to Romney and 14% to Obama, that's a net switch of 9 points to Romney because of the debates. Was Obama ever ahead in Ohio by nine points? In politics, that's HUGE, and the truth is precisely the opposite: the Presidential debates made all the difference.

It would have been more accurate to say, "Presidential debates are an important factor in decision making for roughly a third of voters."

I doubt that's an instance of spin. More likely just sloppy summarizing on a deadline. But still, does no one think?

Aging Socialite Is Her Own Lapdog

|
We had to not report the news to have access to it.

The Formerly Gray Lady soul-searches on the topic of quote approval.
It was difficult to find a news outlet that had not agreed to quote approval, albeit reluctantly. Organizations like Bloomberg, The Washington Post, Vanity Fair, Reuters and The New York Times have all consented to interviews under such terms.
“We don’t like the practice,” said Dean Baquet, managing editor for news at The New York Times. “We encourage our reporters to push back. Unfortunately this practice is becoming increasingly common, and maybe we have to push back harder.” 
I am not trying to be incendiary by the following analogy --I'm not suggesting moral equivalence between Obama and Saddam-- but I'm going to ask a question. How far do we go down the road of quote approval before we are here (remember this 2003 column from the CNN Baghdad bureau chief about how they never reported the actual news in Baghdad so they could keep their Baghdad news bureau open?).

Ah for the days of, "If your mother says she loves you, check it out." Or Robert Novak's motto that there are only two kinds of people in this world: sources and targets.

Don't we have to say that the 24 news cycle means the news is always on, but devoid of content? And doesn't that lead precisely to the spectacle of this past week, wherein al-Qaeda murders our Ambassador and personnel, but Mitt Romney is the enemy?

Yes, there's liberal bias in the way the story's been handled. But more there has been the mindset that news consists in quotations from politicians about stories, not in stories. Where are the damn reports from Libya and not from the screen shot outside the West Wing?


Maybe Divorcés Should Boycott Chick-fil-A

|
The latest skirmish in the culture war is over whether or not to patronize Chick-fil-A (a popular fast-food franchise known for its chicken sandwich, rich shakes, and observance of the Sabbath, for those of you across the Pond.)

Dan Cathy, President & CFO of Chick-fil-A, granted an interview to The Bibilical Recorder, later distributed by Baptist Press, in which he said among other things that the company was "guilty as charged" of supporting traditional marriage.

The story has morphed into a great hue and cry, with The Usual Suspects on both sides performing as expected. Gay groups are boycotting Chick-fil-A and staging homosexual kiss-ins at the famously family-oriented restaurants. Boston Mayor Thomas Menino and Chicago Mayor Rahm Emmanuel are threatening to prevent Chick-fil-A from operating within their cities' environs.

Gay marriage opponents are naturally rising to Chick-fil-A's defense. In case you're wondering why all of a sudden your friends are tweeting that they're at Chick-fil-A: that's why. Every Wednesday is now Chick-fil-A Wednesday If YOU CARE about Western Civilization AT ALL. Or so Facebook informs me.

Five quick points.

1. The Anchoress as usual gets it right. Hizzoners Menino & Emmanuel are what this blog likes to call Perky Little Tyrants. So far their threats seem to me like mere posturing and bloviating -- they didn't even read what the man said, but more on that later.. Making good on those threats would set a dangerous precedent -- do you have to declare your political beliefs before getting a business license? What kind of thought police crap is that?

(And how stupid is it to declare as beyond the bounds of civic discourse the exact same position President Obama, head of the Democratic Party, professed until oh, 2 minutes ago? Not only do these gentlemen think we all have to "evolve" on the issue of marriage, we now are required to evolve at the exact same pace as the President. )

2. I'm not a believer in corporate giving or the tax code that caused it to develop. Much as I don't approve of unions using member dues to support political candidates and causes, I don't approve of corporations donating to causes without the consent of the workers who helped build the business and make the profits. I think it's unhealthy to inject every transaction of public life with partisan significance, which is the logical result of that policy. But so long as the code is what it is, Chick-fil-A is simply exercising its rights in conformity with the law and a free market, precisely the way companies on the other side of the marriage issue (Starbucks, Home Depot, etc.) do. It is giving to causes it likes. It's not refusing to employ or serve entire constituencies, which is entirely different.

3. Politics ain't beanbag. If a company chooses to inject itself into a political battle, it has no right to cry foul when consumers take that choice into account. You can't give an interview throwing down the gauntlet at a particular constituency and expect them not to react. This is why I haven't really understood the response of friends who promote a boycott of Starbucks because they're pushing gay marriage but are offended and surprised by the gay groups' response to Chick-fil-A. Sauce for the chicken....

4. Turns out that is not what happened here. Chick-fil-A did not take on gay marriage nor insert itself in any way into that debate. Thanks again to the Anchoress, who points us in turn to Terry Mattingly's piece showing that Dan Cathy never said nor was asked a thing about gay marriage. That story is crock from CNN. Here's what Cathy actually said. First of all, he doesn't claim to be running a Christian business.
We don’t claim to be a Christian business,” Cathy told the Biblical Recorder in a recent visit to North Carolina. He attended a business leadership conference many years ago where he heard Christian businessman Fred Roach say, “There is no such thing as a Christian business.”
“That got my attention,” Cathy said. Roach went on to say, “Christ never died for a corporation. He died for you and me.”
“In that spirit … [Christianity] is about a personal relationship. Companies are not lost or saved, but certainly individuals are,” Cathy added. “But as an organization we can operate on biblical principles. So that is what we claim to be. [We are] based on biblical principles, asking God and pleading with God to give us wisdom on decisions we make about people and the programs and partnerships we have. And He has blessed us.”
And then he was asked about his WinShape Foundation, which includes programs to support and save marriages.
The company invests in Christian growth and ministry through its WinShape Foundation (WinShape.com). The name comes from the idea of shaping people to be winners. It began as a college scholarship and expanded to a foster care program, an international ministry, and a conference and retreat center modeled after the Billy Graham Training Center at the Cove.
“That morphed into a marriage program in conjunction with national marriage ministries,” Cathy added.
Some have opposed the company’s support of the traditional family. “Well, guilty as charged,” said Cathy when asked about the company’s position. “We are very much supportive of the family — the biblical definition of the family unit. …
“We are very much committed to that,” Cathy emphasized. “We intend to stay the course,” he said. “We know that it might not be popular with everyone, but thank the Lord, we live in a country where we can share our values and operate on biblical principles.”
You can argue I suppose that if Dan Cathy supports the Biblical view of marriage we know he also opposes same sex marriage. But he didn't make his comments as a dig at gay marriage, but as a support of a marriage culture. He had keeping couples together in view when he spoke. In fact, if there's anything at all to get huffy about in what he said it's this:
We are a family-owned business, a family-led business, and we are married to our first wives. We give God thanks for that.
Married to your first wives? (My God, he is an extremist isn't he?)

It's divorced people who ought to be boycotting!

5. Here we have a story and moral outrage on both sides entirely ginned up by sloppy journalism. (Do read Terry Mattingly's entire piece.) More than sloppy: reckless. Brian Ross and George Stephanopolous are to pay no price for falsely accusing a man of mass murder last week. This week CNN is to pay no price for recklessly endangering the livelihood of thousands of Chick-fil-A employees, who now face a boycott and are inserted into the culture war for no good reason other than journalists have no standards and manage to sink below them even so.

Update: a 6th point. I'd like to thank the two demagogue mayors for so roundly answering the question, "How will same-sex marriage effect me?"